The Identity Trap

by | Oct 2, 2023 | Blog

I say poo-poo to the saying, “Change is the only constant.” I think of ‘constants’ as fundamental internal descriptors of who we are on an individual level. They are the steadfast elements that represent our authenticity, our truest identity, and a heap of opportunity, especially when we’re facing a significant life change.

Many of the women who come to me for life coaching are searching to discover their identity after navigating a significant change in their lives. They want to know: Who am I after leaving a career that almost killed me? Who am I after my kids have left the nest and gone to college? Who am I after my divorce or breakup? Who am I after the death of my parents or my partner? Who am I after retiring as a professional woman with a title? Who am I after menopause?

In the years leading up to ‘after,’ the women I coach formed identities and those identities became their truths. They were mothers and wives. They had responsibility and titles. They were children caring for aging parents. They were younger and sexier than they feel now. The identities they assumed defined their worth and dictated the way they lived their lives.

And I totally get it. Change can be tough. When I left my corporate career, I had to reframe my identity. When my son left for college, I had to reframe my identity. When my Dad died, I had to reframe my identity. There are no short cuts but mindfulness, courage, and curiosity helped me create a path of discovery that led me back to my true self.

Identity (/īˈden(t)ədē/): “the fact of being who or what a person or thing is.”

Here’s what I want you to know. Sure, identities can give you a way to understand yourself, but, they can also become straitjacket like labels that keep you bound and separated from who you authentically- are at a fundamental level. External identity labels only tell a small slice of your whole story. And if you put too much stock in that small slice, it’s super easy to find yourself stuck in the past, missing the present, and getting lost, when the identity you’ve assumed no longer exists. Here’s one example.

One of my clients struggled with her identity after her husband of 30 years died. Her identity of ‘wife’ no longer existed. This rocked her world. In being his wife, she’d forgotten who she was outside of that identity- who she authentically was as a woman. As she worked through her grief of losing him, she got blindsided because she found herself working through the grief of losing the primary identity she’d assumed, as his wife.

The first question I asked her was, “Who were you before you were married?” She had a hard time remembering so, we got grounded in a short meditation and switched gears. A bit later in our conversation she said, “I’ve always been an artist. I’ve always loved animals. I’ve always been a traveler. I’ve always loved to sing.” As she said the words, she smiled as tears ran down her face. That one realization re-connected her what I call her ‘constants’-  a part of herself that was core to who she was authentically-the woman she’d always known and been. Her awareness opened her mindset and gave her a new way to identify with herself. It gave her an opportunity to become something aside from a widow and a way to step into her life after losing her husband.

And you have ‘constants.’ These are the parts of yourself that are fundamental to who you are. The qualities, interests, talents, and gifts, that are always part of you, no matter what stage of life you’re navigating. Mindfulness based life coaching empowers you to connect with your constants. It gives you the freedom to tell your whole story and live a multi dimensional life. Your constants can create possibilities by giving you multiple ways to identify with yourself, independent of fleeting external factors like your work, marital status, sex drive, or age. So, if you’re asking yourself, “Who will I be after…?” you can kick off your journey of self discovery by asking yourself these three questions: Who was I before? Who have I always been? Who do I want to be now? 

If you’d like life-coaching support for your ‘after’ story, send me a note. Let’s grab some time to talk.

Cole Baker-Bagwell

Master Certified Professional Coach

Recent Posts

Jun 10 2026

How to Move Forward After A Layoff

Layoffs could be the theme song of 2026. If you’ve been part of a reduction in force, here are...
Feb 27 2026

The Hidden Variable Dictating AI’s Future: Cognitive Sovereignty

AI leaders aren’t talking about cognitive sovereignty. They’re peddling doom to...
Monks with their dog walking for peace
Feb 11 2026

The Walk for Peace: A Masterclass in Leadership

The Walk for Peace gave us a 2,300-mile masterclass on leadership and the power mindfulness,...
1980's cassette tapes
Feb 10 2026

Rub Dirt On It: Why Your 1985 Mindset is Killing Your Leadership Capacity

Leadership capacity hit a wall? Your 1985 neural pathways may be the culprit. Learn two practices...
Dec 31 2025

Ready to Kick 2025 to The Curb? I See You: Reset Your Mindset, Claim 2026

This last episode of 2025 invites you to reset your mindset and step into 2026 with a one-word...
Dec 19 2025

Boost Your Mindset, Mood & Memories: 15 Free Holiday Vibe Shifters

Boost your mindset, mood, memories by increasing four feel good chemicals with 15 vibe shifters...
Dec 10 2025

From Self-Criticism to Self-Appreciation: 3 Steps to Transform Your Self-Talk and Mindset

Reframing your self-talk transforms your mindset. Learn how to reset from self criticism to self...
Dec 03 2025

Drop the Mental Weight: Stop Overthinking with One Unconventional Practice

Learn how to stop overthinking with one daily practice that will help you drop that mental weight...
Nov 19 2025

Activate Your Authentic Voice: Discover Who You Really Are with Lidia Lins

Ready to activate your authentic voice? Lidia Lins joins us to explore the deep connection between...
Nov 12 2025

My Week With ChatGPT: 4 Human Skills to Stay Ahead In An AI-Driven World

I spent 7 straight days with ChatGPT pressure testing 4 human skills we need to stay ahead and...